Comparison of Drawings & Leadership Descriptors

Drag to rearrange sections
Rich Text Content

Drawing a leader and manager was an interesting exercise.  Both of my drawings compare closely to the leadership and manager descriptors.  Since I've taken management classes before I had some insight into what the descriptors were.  In addition to the descriptors given in the handout I added the importance of a leader to do the right thing as opposed to the managers responsibility  to do things right.  A leader focuses on WHAT can be accomplished while a manager's focus is on HOW things should get done.  Leaders are outcome oriented while managers are rules oriented.

I added a slight variance to the handout in that instead of listing energy as a leadership quality I said that leaders mus energize the system while managers need to ensure stability.  One more difference was that I feel leaders must be concerned with team and the individual as well as the organizational goals.  Managers should be concerned only with the organization's targets and goals.

My drawings match the handout in several areas including:

  1. Leadership at all levels; everyone strategic
  2. long-term results
  3. heart filled with morale and commitment
  4. "customer" focused (i said society)
  5. all together know best: Teamwork
  6. best for organization in society

 

I've highlighted the descriptors below that i feel best describe me.  Although the marks indicate leadership, my functional role often requires a balance between both columns. A find that I must fulfill the management role sometimes while working with my first line supervisors.  

I'm not surprised by the marks but feel that to truly operate as a leader my position requires a higher level in the Department.  I unquestionably see myself as a leader but recognize that good leaders require good managers.  It's also important to state that sometimes when dealing with some of my direct subordinates I have to put my Management hat on and use the skills listed as descriptors of managers.

Leadership

Management

success based on innovation and adaption

success based on predictability

vision and values

goals

energy

plans

lives vision and purpose

defines vision and purpose statements

models values

defines values statements

does the right thing

does things right

leadership at all levels; everyone strategic

top-down strategy

measurement of results

measurement of activities

long-term results, big picture emphasized

short-term results emphasized

systems, aligning the whole, intuitive

linear, rational, analytical

“heart stuff” (e.g., morale, commitment)

“head stuff” (e.g., behavior, compliance)

inspires, creates new ways, coaches, mentors

controls

multiples, situational leadership roles and styles

one best style (plan, organize, delegate, control)

principles

techniques

sets context, pays attention to process

focus on content

everyone responsible for quality

quality control

customer-focused

inward-looking

individual and team effort and reward

Individual effort and reward

all together know best

management knows best

success as the success of others

success as personal success

best for organization in society

best for organization (focused on bottom line)

rich_text    
Drag to rearrange sections
Rich Text Content
rich_text    

Page Comments